MT population synthesis QA cycle 1 bundle review
done synth-reviewer
Task metadata
| id | t_68b443df |
|---|---|
| title | MT population synthesis QA cycle 1 bundle review |
| assignee | synth-reviewer |
| status | done |
| tenant | synthestat |
| priority | 100 |
| workspace_kind | dir |
| workspace_path | /home/synthestat |
| created_by | synth-manager |
| created_at | 2026-05-19 18:41:53 CEST |
| started_at | 2026-05-19 18:46:48 CEST |
| completed_at | 2026-05-19 18:49:49 CEST |
Latest summary
NEEDS_MODEL_FIX for MT run mt_population_review_cycle1_0a09edfb_seed420987. Bundle is present/readable and HARD/FIRM summaries pass, but reviewer approval is blocked by null dwelling household_id values contradicting occupied-dwelling validation semantics, unsupported HH_SINGLE_E/M/Y age semantics against all-1991 persons, and incomplete per-source provenance metadata; report written to /home/synthestat/workspace/manager_handoffs/reviewer/2026-05-19_164843Z_MT_population_review_cycle1.md.
Body
Review the Malta (MT) population synthesis QA cycle 1 bundle produced by parent task t_0e586b96. Project root: /home/synthestat Country: MT Review contract: /home/synthestat/docs/contracts/population_review_bundle.md Release mode: internal research review Review requirements: - Locate the bundle path/run_id from the parent modeler handoff. - Validate contract completeness: required entity files or explicit unavailable.json files; required manifest/diagnostic/provenance/uncertainty/model-note files. - Verify HARD constraints do not break. Check FIRM/SOFT residuals against declared tolerances and make sure relaxed constraints are explicit. - Verify modelled estimates include uncertainty bounds and are not presented as observed facts. - Verify hidden/weakly measured populations are separate uncertainty-aware overlays and do not silently rewrite de jure constraints. - Verify provenance includes source IDs/URLs, retrieval timestamps where applicable, geography levels, reference periods, and quality flags. - Verify missing sources, failed downloads, degraded zones, unavailable layers, and weak evidence are explicit. - Verify finest-geography sparse variables such as occupation/industry/work-school assignment are flagged model-driven unless directly measured. Return exactly one routing verdict in metadata.verdict and in the summary: - PASS - NEEDS_MODEL_FIX - NEEDS_MORE_SOURCES - BLOCKED_INVALID_OUTPUT - EVIDENCE_EXHAUSTED_HUMAN_REVIEW - MODEL_IMPROVEMENT_EXHAUSTED_HUMAN_REVIEW Definition of done: - Complete a structured review handoff with verdict, blocking findings, nonblocking warnings, checked bundle path/run_id, and next recommended branch. - If verdict is NEEDS_MODEL_FIX, specify the concrete model/bundle defects to fix. - If verdict is NEEDS_MORE_SOURCES, specify exactly which evidence/source families are needed and whether synth-marginals-researcher, synth-distributions-researcher, and/or synth-downloader should be routed next. - If verdict is exhausted-human-review, state the human decision needed without pretending precision is possible. Do not modify the modeler bundle except for separate review notes under allowed reviewer handoff/output paths.
Parents
[ "t_0e586b96" ]
Children
[ "t_28afee7e" ]
Runs
| ID | Profile | Status | Outcome | Started | Ended | Summary/error |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 39 | synth-reviewer | done | completed | 2026-05-19 18:46:48 CEST | 2026-05-19 18:49:49 CEST | NEEDS_MODEL_FIX for MT run mt_population_review_cycle1_0a09edfb_seed420987. Bundle is present/readable and HARD/FIRM summaries pass, but reviewer approval is blocked by null dwelling household_id values contradicting occupied-dwelling validation semantics, unsupported HH_SINGLE_E/M/Y age semantics against all-1991 persons, and incomplete per-source provenance metadata; report written to /home/synthestat/workspace/manager_handoffs/reviewer/2026-05-19_164843Z_MT_population_review_cycle1.md. |
Events
| Time | Kind | Payload |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-05-19 18:41:53 CEST | created | {
"assignee": "synth-reviewer",
"status": "todo",
"parents": [
"t_0e586b96"
],
"tenant": "synthestat",
"skills": null
} |
| 2026-05-19 18:46:46 CEST | promoted | null |
| 2026-05-19 18:46:48 CEST | claimed | {
"lock": "vmi3188806:1590352",
"expires": 1779210108,
"run_id": 39
} |
| 2026-05-19 18:46:48 CEST | spawned | {
"pid": 1623497
} |
| 2026-05-19 18:49:49 CEST | completed | {
"result_len": 0,
"summary": "NEEDS_MODEL_FIX for MT run mt_population_review_cycle1_0a09edfb_seed420987. Bundle is present/readable and HARD/FIRM summaries pass, but reviewer approval is blocked by null dwelling household_id values contradicting occupied-dwelling validation semantics, unsupported HH_SINGLE_E/M/Y age semantics against all-1991 persons, and incomplete per-source provenance metadata; report written to /home/synt",
"verified_cards": [
"t_28afee7e"
]
} |
Comments
No comments yet.